Christmas Tree Cake Milkshake Recipe - A Whole Snack Cake Blended In (About $2.75)
The shake that tastes like the snack cake aisle at Christmas
Some holiday treats you eat. This one you drink - and it tastes like the inside of a Christmas tree snack cake got blended with a vanilla milkshake, because that is exactly what happened. One whole tree-shaped snack cake goes INTO the blender with the ice cream, and a second one rides on top like it owns the place. The glass gets lined with red candy and frozen first, so every sip comes with that red-swirled diner look - for about $2.75 a shake.
Ingredients
- About 1/2 oz red candy melts (a small handful of wafers)
- 4 big scoops vanilla ice cream (about 2 cups)
- 1/2 cup milk
- 2 Christmas tree snack cakes, unwrapped - 1 for the blender, 1 for the top
- Whipped topping, for the swirl
- Green sanding sugar, about 1 tsp
- 1 red-and-white striped paper straw (optional)
How to make it
- Melt the red candy melts (microwave in 20-second bursts, stirring). Spoon and swirl the melted candy around the inside of a tall milkshake glass - ribbons and drips, not a solid coat.
- Freeze the lined glass for 5 minutes, until the lining is set hard.
- Add the ice cream, milk, and 1 whole tree snack cake (crumble it in with your hands) to a blender.
- Blend until smooth and speckled - fine cake flecks all through, no chunks.
- Pour into the frosty lined glass.
- Top with a tall swirl of whipped topping and a sprinkle of green sanding sugar.
- Perch the second tree snack cake on top, point up, add the straw, and serve with a long spoon.
The honest cost
About $2.75 a shake: the 5-count box of tree snack cakes is $2.97 (59 cents a cake - two per shake = $1.19), a 48 oz tub of vanilla ice cream is $2.97 (four scoops = $0.99), plus $0.10 of milk, $0.22 of red candy melts, $0.17 of whipped topping, and $0.07 of sanding sugar. If your pantry starts bare, the buy-in is $15.34 in products plus milk - and that box and tub make more shakes after the first one, so shake number two costs pocket change.
Tips
- Cold glass, fast hands: the candy lining holds best when the glass stays frosty until the shake hits it.
- Making two smaller shakes? Split everything between two 8 oz glasses.
- Any store-brand tree-shaped snack cakes work here - this recipe is brand-agnostic on purpose.
More Dollar Gourmet fun
- Love a party drink with a gimmick? Our Swamp Cubes do the same trick for Halloween: https://dollargourmet.blogspot.com/2026/10/swamp-cubes-halloween-party-drink.html
- Got candy to use up? The Leftover Halloween Candy Bark melts it into something giftable: https://dollargourmet.blogspot.com/2026/11/leftover-halloween-candy-bark-recipe.html

Comments
Post a Comment