Loaded Baked Potato Soup Recipe - Creamy, Chunky & About $1.60 a Bowl
The one rule of potato soup: creamy AND chunky
Most potato soup recipes fail in one of two directions - a thin broth with cubes floating in it, or a blender-smooth puree that eats like glue. This one takes the third road. The potatoes simmer in seasoned broth until tender, then get mashed right in the pot - but only partway. The mashed half melts into the broth and makes the soup creamy; the un-mashed half stays in soft chunks. Then cream and cheddar go in low and slow, and every bowl gets loaded like the baked potato it is named after: bacon, more cheddar, scallions. On the side, crescent rolls with the garlic butter and cheddar rolled up inside, baked until the cheese peeks out of the seams - because a whole cheesy garlic crescent is, structurally, a soup spoon.
The honest math, in two parts. The soup alone: about $1.60 a bowl, $9.58 for a six-bowl pot. Three pounds of russets out of a $3.27 five-pound bag (about $1.96), a $1.50 carton of broth, three-quarters of a cup of cream (about $1.11 of the $2.96 pint), a full $1.97 bag of shredded cheddar between the pot and the toppings, four slices of bacon (about $1.31), a 68-cent bunch of scallions, an onion, and pantry butter and garlic. With the cheesy garlic bread: about $2.32 a bowl - the tube of crescent dough ($2.98) and a second bag of cheddar are the splurge, and I am not going to pretend otherwise. I sketched this dinner at $1.25-1.50 with the bread and the price check said no. Soup night is still soup night; the bread is just honestly priced.
What you need
Soup
- About 3 lb russet potatoes, peeled and cut into 1-inch cubes
- 4 slices bacon - about $1.31 of a $3.94 pack
- 2 Tbsp butter + 1 medium yellow onion, diced + 2 cloves garlic
- 1 carton (32 oz) chicken broth - $1.50
- 3/4 cup heavy cream - the $2.96 pint
- 2 cups shredded cheddar, divided - one $1.97 bag
- 1 bunch scallions - about $0.68
- Salt and pepper, and a splash of milk if you want it looser
Cheesy garlic bread
- 1 tube (8 count) crescent roll dough - $2.98 (6 cheesy crescents; the extra 2 triangles bake plain)
- 4 Tbsp softened butter + 1 tsp garlic powder
- 1 cup shredded cheddar - half of a second $1.97 bag
How to make loaded baked potato soup
- Crisp the bacon in the Dutch oven, lift it out and crumble it, and keep about a tablespoon of the drippings.
- Soften the onion in the drippings plus the butter, 3-4 minutes; garlic in for the last 30 seconds.
- Add the potatoes and the whole carton of broth, season, and simmer 15-18 minutes until the cubes are completely fork-tender.
- Mash in the pot - partway. A dozen presses with a potato masher: half the potatoes disappear into the broth and thicken it, half stay as chunks. Never blend it.
- Cream and cheddar on low. Stir in the cream, then 1 1/2 cups of cheddar a handful at a time until melted and glossy. No boiling after the cheese - that is what keeps it from going grainy. Splash of milk if it is thicker than you like.
- Load every bowl with bacon, the remaining cheddar and scallions.
- The bread: brush the dough triangles with garlic butter, sprinkle with cheddar, roll them up from the wide end and bake at 375°F for 10-12 minutes until puffed and deep golden. Serve whole and dunk freely.
Why this one earns its place in the soup rotation
It is a whole dinner - protein, starch, dairy, the works - out of one pot and one pan, and it is built on the cheapest vegetable in the store. The leftovers thicken overnight and reheat beautifully with a splash of milk, which makes it a cook-once-eat-twice pot in the middle of the busy season. And the texture trick - mash some of it, not all of it - works on every potato soup you will ever make from here on.
One pot, six bowls, about $1.60 a bowl before the bread. Soup night, done right.
Prices checked Nov 5, 2026 at Walmart. Your store may vary a few cents.

Comments
Post a Comment