Make Your Pie Crust Now: Freeze It Two Ways and Skip the Thanksgiving Rush
Every Thanksgiving kitchen has the same bottleneck: the pies get made last, when the counter is already full and the oven schedule is a negotiation. The crust is the one part that does not care when you make it. Pie dough freezes beautifully - so make it this week, while the kitchen is calm and the grocery store is not yet a contact sport, and Thanksgiving morning becomes just fill and bake.
The dough: half butter, half shortening
This is the budget classic, and it earns the title. All-butter crusts are lovely and pricey and a little fussy; all-shortening crusts are cheap and sturdy and taste like not much. Half and half splits it right down the middle: real butter flavour, shortening's easy handling, and a crust that flakes.
For ONE 9-inch single crust (double it for a two-crust pie):
- 1 1/4 cups all-purpose flour
- 1/2 tsp sugar, 1/2 tsp salt
- 4 Tbsp cold butter, cut into small cubes
- 4 Tbsp cold shortening
- 3-5 Tbsp ice water
The honest math: flour about 16 cents - butter about 44 cents - shortening about 16 cents - salt and sugar about 2 cents. Total: about 78 cents a crust. The refrigerated store crusts run about $2.50-3 for a 2-pack - that is $1.25-1.50 a crust, for dough you still have to unroll and fit. Two homemade crusts cost about $1.56 all in.
The method
- Cut the fat into the flour. Stir the flour, sugar and salt together, then work the cold butter and shortening in with a pastry blender (or two knives, or your fingertips, fast) until the biggest pieces are pea-size. Those little pieces ARE the flakes - do not mix them away.
- Add ice water a spoonful at a time until the dough just holds together when you squeeze a handful. It should look shaggy, not smooth.
- Press it into a flat disc. Gather it, press it into a round disc about an inch thick, wrap it well. Flat discs chill faster, freeze faster and thaw evenly - a ball of dough thaws at the edges while the middle stays a rock.
- Freeze it one of two ways (below). Either way it keeps happily for weeks - up to about 3 months - so this week is not even cutting it close.
Route 1: freeze the disc
Wrap the disc tightly and freeze it flat. The night before pie day, move it to the fridge to thaw overnight. In the morning it rolls out fresh, exactly like dough you made that day - because as far as the pie is concerned, you did.
Route 2: freeze it shaped in the pan
Roll the dough out now, fit it into the pan, crimp the edge, and freeze the whole shell. Pie day, it goes straight from the freezer to filled to oven - just give it a few extra minutes of bake time over a fresh shell.
The one rule that matters: a shaped shell freezes only in a METAL or FOIL pan. Never ceramic, never glass. A ceramic or glass pan can crack going from a cold freezer into a hot oven - that is thermal shock, and it ruins the pie and the pan in one loud second. The plain foil pans from the dollar store (about $1.25 a multi-pack, pennies a pan - not counted in the 78 cents above, and we are saying so) are exactly right for this: light, cheap, and they do not care about temperature swings.
While you are in make-ahead mode
The crust is not the only Thanksgiving job that moves to this week. Our Scratch Sage Stuffing starts with bread you can cube and dry on your own schedule, not the turkey's - same calm-kitchen thinking, different pan.
There's a quick video of the whole tip on our TikTok and Reels - the dough, both freeze routes, and the frozen pair, start to finish in about half a minute.

Comments
Post a Comment